Is your Business like the Entrance to a Department Store

September 18, 2023

Thankfully, ours is not! But if I had a dollar for every time I’ve heard that issue, I’d be retired!


Many business owners and managers experience what I call ‘revolving door syndrome’. Their businesses are like the entrance to a major department store…new employees coming in; ex-employees going out. If you’ve experienced this from time to time, you’ll know how costly and disruptive this is.


 A lack of employee retention a complex problem with many interconnected facets, including systems, leadership, remuneration, training and communication (you communicating proactively with your team). There are several more but let's focus on the starting position, recruiting the right people.


In my 20+ years of recruiting, I would put it down to one thing – selection. Yes it's obvious but many managers and recruiters seem to overcomplicate the process or simply don’t use one except the gut feeling!


The three primary ingredients and their effectiveness in selecting the right people are:


1. Skills and experience – least effective

2. Attitude, behaviours, mindset – very effective

3. Organisational fit – extremely effective


Skills


Unless you're recruiting brain surgeons, this is fairly straightforward. But to know what skills you’re seeking, you first have to know the skills and experience required for your job. 


I suggest starting with a position description that outlines responsibilities, some detail about how the person will fulfil these responsibilities and some KPIs or measures so you are able to set out expectations, i.e. 20 units produced per week, less than 1% defect rate. All the information in your PD can be used for interview questions, and constructing a job ad.



Attitude


How do you know someone has the right attitude? Depends!


Ok, you hate that answer, but it's all relative. So I suggest thinking about or writing down the sort of behaviour you’re expecting. Turning up on time is a behaviour, so it's turning up every day. Putting effort in and taking ownership of learning is also categorised as behaviour. Most things you want your people to have when they arrive on their first day and require zero skill are behaviours, it's how they think and naturally act. Can be taught and changed by some people…sometimes.



Cultural Fit


Cultural fit is the most effective selection tool, yet very few managers or recruiters spend anything like enough time assessing this selection criterion. This can be fluffy stuff and hard to quantify, but the investment in assessing and selecting an overall fit will pay dividends.


There are a ton of questions you can ask but it's important to be clear in your own mind about how things actually happen in different work situations in your business….and not necessarily what is written on a fancy picture frame in reception! If everyone there shares common traits like taking pride in their work, collaborating, or being innovative it makes sense to recruit people with similar characteristics.


Knowing how you do things makes asking a bunch of carefully cultivated and worded questions less important (candidates will give you all their practised answers anyway). What is much more valuable is the information you gather from a conversational interview. And the sort of conversation you’ll have is relaxed, and open and invites them to talk freely about their previous experience at work, what they liked, and didn’t like and drilling down into the areas that relate back to how you get work done, the environment, people, customers and so on. The same also applies to their out-of-work experiences, hobbies, family, sports, interests etc. These normally give you good information about fit also.


What if applicants are hard to find?


If you have a small applicant pool, I suggest it's never a good idea to compromise on attitude, behaviours, values or fit, commonly known as soft skills. But you can sometimes compromise on skills, competencies and ability. That’s teachable, the soft skills are usually very time-consuming and challenging to teach. But hey, you might feel good about shifting someone’s attitude for the better, and we salute you!



Summary


Time is our biggest enemy, and also our most valuable investment, so it follows that what you do with your time will dictate your return. 


The best returns typically come from things that build or make your business or department better, rather than you doing stuff or working in it. Recruiting great people and building a Team is a core part of working on it. I’ve seen some amazing turnarounds because supervisors or managers have bitten the bullet and decided to commit some regular weekly time to work on their department, made a few tweaks to their recruiting effort and bingo. Obviously, the more thorough you are, the better, but implementing one or two things to improve your success rate will make a positive difference. 

If you’d like to find out more or how IRP can help, feel free to call us on (08) 9477 7999 or email us hello@irp.net.au.


2 workers shaking hands. Both wearing shirts.
By Peter Spark July 16, 2025
Learn how you can fight churn and build high-performing teams by strategically partnering with a recruitment agency for better hiring, onboarding, and retention.
A happy team working in a warehouse
By Peter Spark June 25, 2025
Learn how to tackle high employee turnover and improve engagement with our expert advice. Dive into our latest blog for actionable solutions.
Artificial Intelligence
By Peter Spark June 12, 2025
For recruiters, AI does (or will do) all the painstaking, monotonous recruitment admin work. It’s amazing at providing instantly usable recruitment tools such as candidate marketing material or interview questions. And it’s far better and faster at it than me, or most recruiters I’ve come across. But that’s where the AI story ends, at least for the time being.
By Peter Spark May 29, 2025
Looking for interview techniques that work? Learn how to conduct an interview and confidently hire the right candidate with these expert tips.
Gen Z reshaping the workforce
By Peter Spark May 13, 2025
We can resist it or embrace it, either way Gen Z is reshaping workplaces. This generation of employees will change how Australian workplaces function, influencing shifts in work preferences, technology and workplace culture. Read our latest article to find out how to embrace Gen Z transformation in the workplace and how to prevent Generation Z from job hopping.
A group of 3 warehouse workers wearing yellow hi-vis jackets talking to their managers
By Peter Spark April 15, 2025
In an environment where Australia’s productivity growth is lagging, the onus falls on businesses and their leaders to drive meaningful change. As this article highlights, boosting labour productivity doesn’t require radical innovation or world-first breakthroughs. It’s about consistently applying proven strategies: investing in training, refining processes, leveraging technology, and creating a culture where employees are engaged and empowered to perform at their best.
A manager with their coworkers
By Peter Spark April 9, 2025
Learn how to spot early signs of burnout in blue collar workers. This manager’s guide covers key symptoms, causes, and strategies for timely support.
Staff discussing employee who has not shown up for work in their blue-collar warehousing job.
By Peter Spark March 18, 2025
Learn how to handle employee absenteeism in blue-collar workplaces. Discover strategies to prevent no-shows and take legal steps if needed.
Worker in warehouse after being hired by a skilled employment agency for his role in Perth.
By Peter Spark February 26, 2025
Struggling to find reliable workers? Discover how a skilled employment agency like IRP helps businesses save time, reduce turnover, and secure top talent.
A blue graph and a pen
By Charlotte Cautley February 19, 2025
The 2025 Australian employment landscape presents both challenges and opportunities. High job participation offers a larger talent pool, but skills shortages and cost-conscious hiring demand innovative recruitment. Our blog dives into some key findings on the Australian Employment Outlook 2025 to help your business prepare.